17th meeting on the Standard on Instrumental Odour Monitoring Systems took place last week

am . . Zugriffe: 97

Bland Alman Plot2
   Last Monday took place the 17th meeting of Working Group 41 (WG41) that is dealing on the new standard for Instrumental Odour Monitoring Systems (IOMS). This meeting was focusing on the statistics behind the Quality Assurance Level 1 (QAL1) of IOMSs. There are some aspects that make IOMS special as compared to other Automatic Measuring Systems (AMS) and one of these aspects is the cost of comparing the electronic signal of the IOMS with that of the reference method EN 13725.

   One of the key issues addressed many times during the WG41 meetings is that of the number of samples that should be taken in order to make QAL1 checks viable for IOMS manufacturers. Dynamic Olfactometry comes at a cost and odour is not a substance, it is a class. The question is: how many samples should be taken in order to have a representative picture of the IOMS performance?

   Every year in Europe a few hundreds of AMS makers undergo QAL1 procedures like these of Germany. The idea is to evaluate the performance of the devices with a procedure that can be taken as a reference for further checks on QAL2, QAL3 and AST. However, life is easy when you have a stable reference material or an electronic reference method that can be used at a low cost per sample. Unfortunately, there is no reference material for ambient odours. Also, a sample that has to be analysed within 30 hours cannot be considered that stable.

   The more samples you take, the better confidence interval you get for your IOMS, but the cost of in this case grows quickly at range of 100-250 € per sample.

 This is when economics come at stake in the standardization world. It is also when statistics come to help economics.

  Two statistic approaches have being discussed during the last two meetings. The Bland–Altman plot approach and the Chebyshev's inequality.

   The Bland–Altman statistic approach is great to tackle the limitations that a correlation coefficient have, by looking at the differences of the results at different odour concentrations. However, this statistical approach assumes a normal distribution of the results. If there is a reduced number of samples, which is the scenario that the WG41 is targeting, then the power of the test to check if the data is really normal is very low, and therefore it is difficult to be certain that the data is gaussian-distributed.

 Chebyshev's inequality does not require a normal distribution of the data, so there is no need to have a large amount of data to check IOMS performance, and that is why the group decided to choose Chebyshev's inequality. Unfortunately that decision comes at a painful cost as it brings a wider confidence interval.

   A few other important issues were discussed during this meeting, but there is no space in this humble website to describe everything discussed in CEN working groups in detail, nor is the aim of this short text. Should you be interested in joining in the group and learning more about the future developments of this standard, we encourage you to contact your national standardization body to learn the procedure to be part of the group. Everyone is welcomed!

Picture source: wikipedia

 


   If you find this article interesting, you might also be interested in these articles:

 

Kommentare (0)

There are no comments posted here yet

Einen Kommentar verfassen

  1. Posting comment as a guest.
Anhänge (0 / 3)
Share Your Location

Please note that this site uses cookies in order to work properly.

See more about our cookie policy Learn more

I understand

Please read the following to learn more about our cookies policy:

 

What are cookies?

   A cookie is a text file stored in a user’s web browser on any device they use to access a website that holds information regarding the user’s visit, such as preferences. When the user returns, the browser provides the cookie with the stored information to the site.

What cookies are used for?

   Cookies are used for adjusting a website’s content to fit a user’s preferences and optimize the website. They store useful information that improve the user’s experience of a website. They are most commonly used for:

  •     Recognizing the type of device a user is browsing with and any preferences applied to optimize the website specifically for the device.
  •     Creating statistics that help website owners to understand how their users interact with their website, which allows them to improve their structure and content.

What types of cookies are used?

   There are two types of cookies: persistent cookies and session cookies. Persistent cookies remain on your hard drive for a period of time specified in the cookie’s file parameters or until removed manually. When you return to a website and it requires you to login again despite previously storing your login information, it is usually because the persistent cookie expired; this helps to increase security while maintaining accessibility.

   Session cookies, on the other hand, are used temporarily and expire once the website or browser is closed. They are used to track user activity on a website during a single visit. When a website requires that you verify your age or location once every visit before allowing you to view content and without requiring additional personal details, that is a session cookie at work.

Do cookies include personal data?

   If there is a need for the collection of personal information, such as for creating accounts, then cookies may store personal information. However, it is required by data protection law that users are informed of the collection of personal data. This data will also be encrypted to render it inaccessible for unauthorized users.

Managing cookies

   By default, browsers are configured to accept cookies. However, these settings may be changed to block cookies entirely, or to inform the user each time they are used. Detailed information about cookies and the options associated with them are available in each browsers’ settings.

Which cookies does collect olores.org?

   Olores.org collect cookies for 2 purposes:

  • Register statistical data.
  • Set language preferences.

   In addition we use third party cookies through Statcounter to collect different data.

StatCounter Analytics Cookies

   StatCounter is a web analytics service. We use StatCounter to track activity on our website. These stats help us to understand how people are interacting with our website and to improve the design and functionality of our site so that we can offer a better online experience to our visitors. If you visit olores.org, a StatCounter analytics cookie (called "is_unique") may  be placed in your browser.  This cookie is used only to determine whether you are a first-time or returning visitor and to estimate unique visits to the site. No personal information is stored in the cookie.

Refuse Statcounter cookies.

You may set your browser to refuse/accept StatCounter analytics cookies by clicking here.

NOTES:

    • Your decision to refuse/accept StatCounter analytics cookies applies to all websites which use the StatCounter service (including the StatCounter site itself).
    • If you refuse all StatCounter analytics cookie, a refusal cookie (called "refusal_cookie") will be set to remember this preference and any existing StatCounter analytics cookies in your browser will be destroyed.
    • If you delete/remove/destroy the refusal cookie, you must revisit this page in order to re-set your preference.
    • The refusal cookie is set only for your current browser and machine. If you use multiple browsers/machines, you must set a refusal cookie in each case.
    • You can also change your cookie settings directly in your browser. Learn more about cookies and how to manage them here: http://www.allaboutcookies.org/cookies/index.html
    • Or you can learn about how to adjust cookie settings for specific browsers here: